The Commission submitted its report to the Government on July 30, A wide spectrum of issues including quality of education in relation to academic achievement of students and performance level of schools, drastic reduction of school dropout, development of skills for wage and self-employment through vocationalization of education, rejuvenating curriculum reform process, language development, education in universal human values, overhauling the system of governance, have been reflected upon in the report of the Commission.
The very setting up of this Commission is a pointer to the expectations the State has from the reformed system of education in the State. This is one State in the Country which can be legitimately credited with this pioneering decision. The work strategy adopted by the Commission included commissioning position-cum-issue papers on various sectors of education, thematic concerns needing special attention and the status of educational institutions in the State.
In addition to obtaining relevant information and eliciting views and opinions through analytical papers, the Commission collected a lot of information through 25 structured questionnaires on all aspects of education in the State of Mizoram. The other strategy adopted by the Commission was interaction with a stakeholders to add on to its understanding of various issues relevant to education in Mizoram.
The Commission also visited institutions to have an actual feel of the ground realities. Click here to view full page. The Group consists of Assistant Professor, Dept. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. High School. New York: Harper and Row. Politics, Markets, and America's Schools. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution. New York: McGraw-Hill. Fixing Urban Schools. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Equity and Adequacy in Education Finance.
Lessons from Houston. New York: Teachers College Press. New York: The Free Press. Berkeley: McCutchan. Restructuring Schools: Capturing and Assessing the Phenomena.
Washington, DC: U. Government Printing Office. Governing America's Schools: Changing the Rules. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Susan H. Fuhrman and Betty Malen. New York: Falmer. Diane Ravitch. New York: Simon and Schuster. America An Education Strategy, revised edition. The Condition of Education Washington, DC:U. Reports compiled by individuals or commissions suggesting reforms for public education have appeared throughout America's postcolonial history. Beginning in the late nineteenth century, committees and commissions of prominent individuals became popular for suggesting innovations to cure some educational ills.
Since the release of the National Commission on Excellence in Education's landmark report, A Nation at Risk, reform reports have peppered the landscape on a wide array of topics affecting K—12 and higher education. Most of the waves of reform since the s have been spearheaded by a high-profile study of schooling containing a clarion call regarding the need for improvements.
Indeed, reform-by-commission has become a mainstay in the arsenal of those hoping to change schools. Those specifically examining the reform-by-commission process have come to a series of conclusions about these reports: 1 they have been around for a long time; 2 they tend to suggest changes in a very general manner; 3 they rarely attend to the significant issues in the implementation of reforms; and 4 their specific recommendation have had little direct impact on schools.
That said, it is also clear that reform reports provide the rhetorical and symbolic context for reforms to be considered, as they denounce perceived problems and attempt to incite a sense of urgency demanding resolution. Educational reform reports can be separated into three distinct periods. The first period, the period of early reform-report activity, includes the few reports generated in the United States up until the late nineteenth century.
The second period, the era of Progressive reforms, roughly covers the late nineteenth century up until the s. The final period, the era of the modern reform report, began in the early s. A number of reports of Prussian and French educational innovations heightened interest in improving America's schools. For example, the German professor Johann Friederich Herbart published a volume on the psychology of the art of teaching in , while a Frenchman, Victor Cousin, published a report on the Prussian system of preparing teachers that was reprinted in English in The first U.
Most significant among these were the reports of Horace Mann, the secretary of the State Board of Massachusetts in the late s and s.
Mann's twelve annual reports covered a broad range of topics and decried the poor efficiency of the public schools. His reports analyzed topics including the moral purposes of schooling, the curriculum, libraries, pedagogical methods, the quality and training of teachers, discipline, school facilities, and church-state relations regarding public schools.
Mann urged the standardization of the schools. Toward the end of the early reform period, the analyses of Joseph M. Rice, the editor of Forum magazine, were published. Rice, a pediatrician who had studied pedagogy in Germany, visited hundreds of urban classrooms in thirty-six cities during the s. He found the conditions and methods of instruction deplorable. Rice eventually designed a simple method of testing spelling to make more reliable evaluations and reported his findings in a series of articles appearing in Forum.
As the design and nature of schooling in the United States unfolded during the nineteenth century, reports emerged that depicted the condition of American education and offered various remedies for reform.
The pace of reports about schools intensified as the country expanded west and the American population grew. This pattern was evident in the era of Progressive reforms. From the s until the s a number of key education reports were published. These ranged from blue-ribbon commissions produced by elite educators and business persons to studies of schools prepared by prominent individual researchers.
In this period the practice of conducting surveys of individual school districts was popularized. A textbook on educational history by John Russell and Charles Judd of the University of Chicago reported an astounding 3, educational surveys between and Supporters of this burgeoning examination of schools stressed the importance of using scientific techniques to inform policy.
Beginning in the s the National Education Association NEA , the leading professional education organization, produced a number of reports, the first and most notable being the report of the Committee on Secondary School Studies chaired by Harvard president Charles Eliot , the Report of the Committee of Ten. The report identified the lack of uniformity in secondary programs and college admission requirements and sought to formulate curriculum and admissions requirements that would bring some harmony to secondary and higher education.
Though scholars differ in their interpretation of the impact of this report's findings, the report did force high schools to work towards greater uniformity in curriculum. In response to the tremendous growth in secondary school enrollment during the early decades of the twentieth century, the NEA established the Committee on the Reorganization of Secondary Education, which produced The Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education in Published by the U.
Department of Education, the document identified several means of preparing students for their duties as citizens, workers, and family members. The bulk of the report dealt with the goals of education in a democracy, the main objectives of education seven were identified , and the role of secondary education in achieving these objectives. Key recommendations included compulsory schooling for at least eight hours a week until age eighteen and the creation of junior and senior high schools—with a comprehensive high school being one with a core curriculum, variables depending on vocation, and electives to accommodate special interests.
The report reflected much of the thinking on education at the time, though its release during World War I no doubt affected its impact. Issues of Secondary Education and Functions of Secondary Education produced recommendations and key functions for secondary schools, including the idea of universal secondary school; curriculum beyond college preparatory, which was differentiated to meet specific needs; greater articulation between elementary and secondary schools; and, most controversially, that students should be eliminated from school once it was apparent that they would no longer benefit from being there.
In the first document, schooling was characterized as an institution that should be run by professionals with great academic freedom. Schools were to be run in a climate protective of democratic and scientific principles. The Purposes document amplified the key aims laid out in the Cardinal Principles. Some argued, however, that these recommendations were out of step with burgeoning issues related to the control of American youth.
The Progressive Education Association undertook several studies, the most prominent of which was the Eight-Year Study, the findings of which were released in This landmark evaluation project included twenty-nine secondary schools with Progressive curricula whose students were studied for eight years. Several colleges agreed to accept students from these programs who didn't meet usual entrance requirements.
The evaluation matched 1, pairs of students from Progressive and conventional high schools across an array of variables in college. Much of the impact of the study was clearly blunted by its release during World War II, and although little remained of the programs in the Progressive schools years after the study, the evaluation design served as the model for studies for decades.
Rereleased in to account for postwar changes, this report made suggestions for improving secondary education. At that time, more than half of all students never completed high school, yet the growing population and an increased faith in the power of schooling were swelling enrollments. Later in the s, the Carnegie Corporation sponsored James Conant's The American High School Today, which involved visitations to fifty-five schools in eighteen states. Schools were evaluated, and it was determined that academically talented students were not being challenged.
Key ingredients of successful schools were found to include strong school board members, superintendents, and principals; twenty-one specific recommendations for curriculum were included. Probably the most significant report of the s was the federally funded research study Equality of Educational Opportunity, published in Authored by James Coleman and associates, the report examined data from , students in 4, schools.
The educational and socioeconomic backgrounds of students' families were found to be the most important variables explaining achievement, far outweighing the impact of school or teacher variables. These findings inspired several decades of debate, affecting a variety of school-related policies. In the s the Kettering Foundation created the National Commission on the Reform of Secondary Education, which worked on updating the Conant findings.
Its report, The Reform of Secondary Education, focused primarily on alternatives to the traditional high school curriculum and a general definition for all American high schools.
Most of the reports in this period were driven by the push for scientific inquiry and the expanding role of schooling in American culture. In the early s, highly visible reports underscored perceived problems and offered solutions for change.
The s became the decade of the reform report starting with the publication of Mortimer Adler's The Paideia Proposal in With the release of A Nation at Risk, the most widely acclaimed report of this genre, an unprecedented period of reform report activity began. It stated that a "rising tide of mediocrity" had overcome America's schools, and that if another nation had tried to impose such mediocrity on U.
These recommendations were debated from statehouse to statehouse across the country. It stated that a "rising tide of mediocrity" had overcome America's schools, and that if another nation had tried to impose such mediocrity on U. These recommendations were debated from statehouse to statehouse across the country. Though the recommendations may not have been followed exactly, the atmosphere for reform generated by the report ushered in a reform period unlike any other in the nation's history.
Other reports soon followed. Obviously, diverse entities focused on education, and no reforms could be promulgated without a commission-style report.
This reliance on reform reports continued unabated throughout the s. Key areas for scrutiny included teacher education A Nation Prepared [], Tomorrow's Teachers [] , educational administration Leader's for America's Schools[] , improving school performance Time for Results [] , and strengthening the economy through schooling Investing in Our Children [], Children in Need [].
The pace of reform-report activity continued in the s and the early part of the twenty-first century. It appears that any government agency or interest group wishing to propose a series of educational reforms often launch their initiative with a reform report.
With the growth of the Internet and its ability to deliver information quickly and cheaply, reports continue to emerge and are readily available to anyone with access to a computer. What can be said of reform reports across America's history? Clearly, such reports have been a mainstay of those interested in schools, though their use grew dramatically towards the latter part of the twentieth century. This history suggests that they will continue as a means of examining aspects of schooling and promoting particular solutions.
Whether being merely symbolic or ceremonial in terms of creating a climate for considering change, or more directly functional in promoting specific policies into practice, they operate as a form of trickle-down reform, where some government agency or other body sets out policy recommendations for policymakers or those close to schools to consider.
The policies that ultimately appear may not be as initially intended, but the reform reports help set the tone for the educational reform agenda that policymakers consider. The Paideia Proposal. New York: Macmillan. New York: Harper and Row. Does School Quality Matter? A Nation Prepared: Teachers for the 21st Century. City School Surveys. New York: Teachers College Press. Equality of Educational Opportunity.
Washington, DC: U. Government Printing Office. Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education. Issues of Secondary Education. Functions of Secondary Education. Investing in Our Children. New York: Committee for Economic Development. Children in Need. Report of the Committee on Secondary School Studies. The American High School Today. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Unique Functions of Education in American Democracy. The Purposes of Education in American Democracy. Education for All American Youth. Washington, DC: Fordham Foundation. Commissions, Reports, Reforms, and Educational Policy. Westport, CT: Praeger. Willie and I. New York: Greenwood Press. The Essential Profession.
0コメント